Talk:Absolute Thespian Islet
What happened to this article? I remember there was a cool table, and different characters. Also, the tribe names were different and more funny. I really liked the old version. ----Happyface414 (talk|blog|contribs) 23:14, 30 May 2012 (UTC)
I asked for permission to make changes into it, and that's what I did. If you don't like it, there are other 5,525 articles (and counting) you may like --PenBlooeR 23:42, 30 May 2012 (UTC)
- LOL! Nice one. --
23:55, 30 May 2012 (UTC)
- I really suggest changing the Story, then. You inadvertently created two parallel storylines that will confuse readers. Feey, discussion pages are for productive discussions, please. ----Happyface414 (talk|blog|contribs) 23:52, 30 May 2012 (UTC)
- I don't really like writing stories, I prefer making the list of episodes... I'll think about what to do with the story, because it shouldn't be just deleted. Maybe it can be used by someone else in the future, or just keep it there for history. --PenBlooeR 00:03, 31 May 2012 (UTC)
- I really suggest changing the Story, then. You inadvertently created two parallel storylines that will confuse readers. Feey, discussion pages are for productive discussions, please. ----Happyface414 (talk|blog|contribs) 23:52, 30 May 2012 (UTC)
Not what I expected! :'([edit]
Penblooe, when I heard you say that you were going to complete ATI in my honor, my heart skipped a beat and I leaped for joy, thrilled beyond measure that you would honor my tireless work and give it the live and episodes it do deserved.
Looking through my phone's RSS as I passed curfew and headed to bed, I realized a horrible fact.
You deleted every one of my characters, de-diversified the species available to play, changed the theme names, distanced the in-universe references and diversions from the real deal, and made it ATI in name only.
I am heartbroken and I feel betrayed, Penblooe. Your edits are great, the colored rows in the table are beautiful, and the episodes idea was better than ATIS. For these, I commend you.
-but you changed everything. You cast me out into the cold and made the characters and my entire idea unoriginal and saddening. I am disappointed, for example, at the copy paste pasta for the character gallery. Whete's the effort? The originality? The love?
When making a parody, don't be TOO CLOSE to the original. My ATI was homage and tribute to TDI as well as a fun spirited parody; to me, yours just looks like a clone of the real deal.
I am very disappointed in this and feel somewhat betrayed because I joyously gave you permission, thinking that one if my greatest dreams- someone continuing and injecting fresh blood into something I never finished -had come true.
Nope. Itʻs just Chuck Testa a hollow promise.
😥
Alright, have it back then. I'm sorry for whatever I've done, however bad it was. I just thought I could do something that isn't Willy and Kody because I'm getting tired of it, but whenever I try I fail. I should've known I'm not creative whatsoever. meh --PenBlooeR 17:36, 31 May 2012 (UTC)
