Club Penguin Fanon Wiki talk:Council/December 22, 2012/Verdict

From Club Penguin Fanon Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search

My votes were disregarded. How's that fair?--John the Communist Consensus Revolutionary with a :) (CPFW Revolution 2013 Talk|CPFW Revolution 2013 Rants|Rubbish) 02:12, 9 January 2013 (UTC)

I've added my votes which we missed. I presume it was just a mistake, considering that CPFW is a free democratic society. Right?--John the Communist Consensus Revolutionary with a :) (CPFW Revolution 2013 Talk|CPFW Revolution 2013 Rants|Rubbish) 02:12, 9 January 2013 (UTC)
I intentionally avoided your votes (with permission from Swiss), because you just voted "against" on everything, which clearly shows you weren't thinking, but just trying to start crap. --FlagCanada.png TheBroMaster Talk to me! 02:52, 9 January 2013 (UTC)

I agree with BroMaster. I have also seen that you have voted against everything that was proposed. Although you DO have the right to vote, we are suspicious of the reason WHY you voted everything down, which could be a sign that you don't care for whatever was presented and that you didn't bother to look deeply into what it was.

Agent Johnson, I will reconsider this if you at least tell us ALL your reasons for EACH vote that took place on that page. Again, YOU MUST EXPLAIN. If you refuse to explain your reason in detail, we will continue to disregard your votes. Reasons such as "I didn't like any of them" is not detailed enough. Explain why you didn't like any of them.

--Gottfried Pondering.pngUser:Swiss Ninja Clovis Hochstadt Performing.png (My Talk Page) 05:10, 9 January 2013 (UTC)

  • 1: The Main Page is fine. I really don't see much problem with it. Zone really did a great job with it.
  • 2: I love the picture. To convert it to text format would ruin the hard effort that Ninjinian put into it.
  • 3: To have implemented this feature would had been tricky since no extension currently exists for something similar to this, therefore someone would have to make it. Our resources could be spent editing.
  • 4: Rollbacks aren't significant to the overall scheme of things. There is no need to have a page for Rollbacks.
  • 5: We simply don't have enough users for it. I'm in favour of removing it since it's an inactive project and any revival would be useless.
  • 6: As TurtleShroom said, Kwiksilver's theory is the best.
  • 7: We've tried implementing this before and it's never worked. Our resources could be better spent editing.
  • 8: WikiLog isn't a needed feature. It just creates more work for an overstretched team of Staffers. I've been a Staffer before, I know what it's like.
  • 9: We cleared out outdated stuff as SN said.
  • 10: Block-warring is usually resolved by the Staff, who are highly competent in their field of work.
  • 11: I wish I could change my vote here. I thought it would be another abandoned project, then I realised that it had to be done, period. I wanted to change my vote but I couldn't.
  • 12: StarKirby is doing a fine job with FGJ and I hope he continues he effort. However community interest in FGJ has waned and I trust StarKirby 100% to do a good job. Only one person voted For.
  • 13: Consensus is a good system that was sabotaged by AJ/HF bashers. They turned every reasonable discussion into a flame war. Alternative Vote is hard to implement as well. I struggled with that Alternative Vote count and had to do recounts for 3 hours straight to ensure they were right.
  • 14: Not enough information on these 'government reforms'. I needed more clarification but since they could interpreted as anything, I voted against.
  • 15: Removed Feature Picture and Featured Quote? These actually are quite active compared to Featured User, so I don't see a need to remove them.
  • 16: I didn't understand anything that was said. I therefore went with the status quo.
  • 17: I thought I was voting Against for something else, I do apologise for that mistake. Clean up the universe stuff, yes.
  • 18: I'm pretty sure we have a feature like that, we'd just be implementing a redundant code.

I didn't explain since at the time I was in a rush. I took 30 minutes doing this so I think this is a competent explanation.--John the Communist Consensus Revolutionary with a :) (CPFW Revolution 2013 Talk|CPFW Revolution 2013 Rants|Rubbish) 20:24, 14 January 2013 (UTC)

Ok works for me. --Gottfried Pondering.pngUser:Swiss Ninja Clovis Hochstadt Performing.png (My Talk Page) 23:59, 14 January 2013 (UTC)

Retrieved from "https://fanon.clubpenguinwiki.info/w/index.php?title=Club_Penguin_Fanon_Wiki_talk:Council/December_22,_2012/Verdict&oldid=159021"